Krav Maga False Security
I believe in honesty in advertising. Some see this as a fault. I was once told by a fellow Krav instructor, “Your are being held back by your sense of morality.” Another instructor said to me, after I pointed out some ‘inaccuracies’ in his presentation, “Yes, but what if I told you that my presentation gets results? (I.e. more business) what would you say then?”
I would say that the bottom line is if you are a Krav Maga instructor, if you claim to teach self defense, as compared to sports martial arts or fitness martial arts, you should remember that people’s lives are on the line. You should remember that beyond dollars and cents, or Euros or shekels, we are dealing with people’s lives. I would compare us to the police, we have taken upon ourselves the obligation to “Protect and serve”. Yes, we need to make a living, yes, even police officers get paid, but we must remember what is at stake.
I recently saw a Google ad for a Krav Maga school in North America. The ad claims that Krav Maga will give you the techniques and confidence to deal with street situations; with this part I agree totally. However the word “deal with” is rather vague. Does deal with mean you can single handedly defeat all your opponents? Or does it just mean you are better equipped to handle street situations?
Later on the ad claims, “Imagine fearing nobody! You can have the confidence to walk down the street or a dark ally and not worry about might happen or someone who might jump you from around the corner.”
Now with this I take issue! Saying Krav Maga will improve your chances of survival, yes, I believe this to be true. I will say that Krav Maga will give you the tools to minimize damage. But I would never say that you should no longer have to fear anyone. I would certainly not suggest you walk down a dark alley or hang out in a bad neighborhood. Let us be clear, Superman exists only in the movies, he is a fictional character. We are only human.
As IKI instructor Calvin Longtin teaches his young students, “Use common sense before self defense.” Common sense would tell us to avoid that dark alley. “Fear nobody!” What nonsense! Rule number one - respect your opponent, no matter how big or how small he looks. Respecting your opponent means knowing that you have something to fear.
Sometimes we feel invincible, that’s nice, but it is not real. A wise person always respects, I.e. fears, his opponents, he is always aware of potential danger and does everything possible to avoid it.
There are no guarantees in life. We do our best to be prepared, we train as hard as we can, we challenge ourselves and test our techniques and abilities, and, we do our best to avoid trouble.
I believe Krav Maga to be a great self defense system, but no system should replace your God given common sense. “I will use common sense before self defense.”