MAn and community

November 30, 2016, Israel

Honoring true martyrs, two young Germans who stood up to Nazi tyranny.

It is difficult to do the right thing. It is difficult to think of others. It is difficult to share our wealth and our time. And it is difficult to think and see long term. 

Can you see the Mountain?  Abraham asked his son Isaac. 

Yes I can father, said the young Isaac. Then you come with me, said Father Abraham. And then Abraham turned to the two others, the helpers who packed and led the donkeys. 

Can you see the Mountain.

No, we cannot see a thing.

Then stay here with the donkeys, Abraham replied. A people who are no different from donkeys, no more able to see than donkeys.

It is not easy to see the Mountain, the future, the greatness than can lie ahead. Can you see the long term consequences of your actions? If you cannot, then please stay here with the donkeys, as you are really no different from them.

Why should I sacrifice for others, why should I devote myself to a better future for mankind? 

Here is one of the answers.

When we think short term, when we think only of ourselves, then we shall surely suffer the consequences of the long-run.

Imagine we steal a little from the supermarket. No one will know, and we can take a little "two finger discount". But if more people started doing this then the supermarket must raise their prices to cover this loss. After all, it is we who will pay for it, in one form or another.

We will always pay. 

So we steal and they raise the prices. Or, if we steal enough they will close the shop and move away. Either way it is we who will lose out. 

If an attack takes place in our community and a call goes out for neighborhood watch volunteers, but not enough people respond; Too many people thinking...someone else can do that, I am too tired, too busy. Well in the long run this may become a "bad neighborhood". And then all those with money will leave, escape the bad neighborhood, and only the poor and desperate remain. And then they will ask for government support as poor underprivilege people. People will cease to take responsibility for themselves, and society deteriorates.   

And so it goes, and so it goes: If you want to live in a good neighborhood you have to be a good person. You must contribute to the community and not only seek what you can take for yourself. A society where each person tries to milk the system will eventually run out of milk and run itself to the ground. Yes, we must always help the weak. We must always look out for the widows and orphans but we must not let professional beggars take over system. The roots must be deeper than the branches or else the entire tree will collapse.

An American friend offered an insight. After reading my book, "Israel: A Nation of Warriors", he said he finally understood the American Jewish community. He is a police officer and deals a great deal with the Jewish community. He did not understand why they have a volunteer group for everything. "Why don't they just call a regular ambulance?" He wondered, "Why don't they just rely on the paid government services like everyone one else?"

After reading my book he said he understood; the Jewish people are based on community life. We have a "society" for everything; a society for visiting the ill, a society for burying the dead, for helping the bereaved and the needy, a society for securing loans, for trips to Israel. In my grandfather's home town in Hungary, there was even a society for "collecting stray papers from holy books." 

There is such a thing as collective responsibility.

And now a difficult, sensitive issue. A European friend wrote me how many people in her country are still angry with the Americans. Her country was defeated in war, entire cities bombed and many families suffered for a long time. Yes, it is true, in war all people suffer. 

I understand their pain and I understand that, as one friend told me, "We suffered so much because of one stupid little man with an ugly mustache." 

But I also understand this, and here is a powerful lesson for all: We all bear responsibility for our communality and our nation. Yes, it is difficult to stand up to tyranny, it is difficult to fight the monster. But we must. 

Sophie Scholl fought the monster. Yes, one young German girl stood up and said NO, I will not accept this. She paid with her life. On the day she was beheaded by the Nazis she said, Die sonne scheint noch,  the sun still shines, what a beautiful day. What power in the words of a young woman! She is about to die and yet she looks at the glory of the universe, at the eternity of life and proclaims, the sun yet shines! At this moment she becomes united with all the great souls, the holy ones, the martyrs. She is one with creation.

Her brother, also a holy martyr, Hans Scholl, met the same cruel fate and shouted out Es lebe die Freiheit, long live freedom. Their friend and colleague Will Graf, was beheaded on 12 October 1943 in Munich, after six months of solitary confinement. There were others, many others, but not enough.

When they come for your neighbor and you say nothing, because you are afraid for your own fate, you will eventually pay. When your dear friends asks you to hide his children so that they have a chance to survive, but you close the door and tell your wife...there was no one at the door, wrong address, then you will eventually pay. You will pay with your cities being bombed, you will pay with the suffering that you allowed to be inflicted upon others. There is a Judge in this world and payment shall be exacted.

We are responsible for our community, for our nation. If something is wrong we must stand up. If more people stood up during World War Two the results would have been much different, for all of us. But too many people said, "It is not my problem, let the government handle matters". And then, when the payment came due everyone becomes angry and bitter, but they forget that one must always pay one's bills, sooner or later. All our actions have consequences. All of our lack of actions also have consequences.

Man and his Community. One is responsible for the other.

Israel: A Nation of Warriors
by Moshe Katz

"Israel, A Nation of Warriors" 350 pages,

What makes Israeli society Unique?
Historical overview from Biblical times to our own.

Analysis of the Reserve system, Airport security, history of a warrior nation, development of Krav Maga fighting system and mindset.

The unique morality and ethics of the Israeli army and its nation of warriors.

16.99 Paperback

Israel, A Nation of Warriors

$9.99 on Kindle

Israel, A Nation of Warriors

This is required reading for all IKI instructors!