I Was Asked a Question
By Moshe Katz
Israeli Krav International

July 2, 2015. El Al, flight 6, Los Angeles - Israel

Woman in Gold, portrait of Adele Bloch-Bauer, a Jewish Austrian woman. This painting, among countless pieces of art stolen by the Nazis, was eventually sold for 135 million dollars.

This work of art was eventually returned to its legal owner, Maria Altmann of Los Angeles, (formally of Vienna, Austria), but over 100,000 similar works of art have never been returned and are still in the possession of thieves, people who continue to profit from the Nazi era. There are also countless buildings, offices, apartments and homes that were taken from Jews and have never been returned or compensated for.

Neo-Nazism is on the rise, who will take a stand?

I was asked a question...

It was about a year ago, during our Krav Maga Tour and Train session. It was a most honest question, a sincere question, a question that took courage to ask. It was an innocent question.

But this question showed an abysmal lack of knowledge, a glaring hole in one's historical perspective, an insensitivity that cries out to the heavens, a generation that forgot.

I was asked a question, a question born of ignorance, ignorance that can hardly be forgiven.

I was asked a question, by a young German woman. She is certainly not an anti-Semite, she is not a hater but she is part of a new generation that is often obtuse when it comes to the painful past. I have seen this all over Europe, in particular in France - a country that greatly aided the Nazis in their extermination of the Jews of their country. I have seen young people who do not understand the unique suffering of the Jews. These people prefer to live in a Fantasy Land, a fairy tale where "there were a few bad people" but all is good now and "lets stop living in the past".

But this is not true, they are wrong, and on this point there can be no discussion.

I was asked a question...

Her question was not only her own, she asked me in the name of others, her friends back in Germany. They simply did not understand. Perhaps they could not understand, not until they come to Israel, not until they walk a mile in our shoes, a mile that runs through Masada, the sites of ancient battles and Yad Va Shem Holocaust Memorial.

I was asked a question...and it startled me that any European could be so clueless about their past. 

I was asked a question and it shocked me that they could be so uninformed about our lives.

I was asked a question that made my whole being shake...

I was asked....Why does the German government still have to pay this generation of Jews continued Holocaust reparations? Will this never end?

By the end of her stay she fully understood the answer, after long discussions and her participation in Tour and Train Israel Experience, she came around completely. Now she acts as a spokesperson on behalf of the Jewish people of Israel, now she no longer asks, now she explains to others. She continues to visit Israel and to train here with the best.

But I suspect that her audience still does not understand. They must come here.

They must come here.

To must come to terms with themselves, their past, they must come here and live with us for a while. They must complete the journey.

A little history

Everyone talks about the destruction of over six million Jews in Europe during World War Two, crimes committed by the Nazis and their very willing accomplices in many countries, but there is more.

What many ignore is that along with the lives lost much property was lost. The property of millions of Jews, the bank accounts, the homes, businesses and art works, valued at many billions of dollars, was also stolen. Add to this the "back-pay" for slave labor.

On suffering and death there can be no price, but on property there can be.

In September 1951 Chancellor Konrad Adenauer of West Germany addressed his Parliament: "… unspeakable crimes have been committed in the name of the German people, calling for moral and material indemnity … The Federal Government are prepared, jointly with representatives of Jewry and the State of Israel … to bring about a solution of the material indemnity problem, thus easing the way to the spiritual settlement of infinite suffering."

This lead to what became known in Israel simply as "reparations".

I used to work in a bank in Jerusalem. I recall at a certain time each month elderly Jews with foreign accents would come in to collect their reparations, a small monthly stipend from the German government.

Contrary to the understanding of our young German friend it is not "The Jews" who receive this stipend but only Survivors who can prove what they have lost. The vast overwhelming majority of the financial losses of the Jewish people of Europe have never been recovered. What we have received is not even a drop in the ocean.

The minimal sums that are still received are used by elderly survivors to cope on a daily basis. Many of them live below the poverty line. Many suffer with various forms of depression and mental illness. Many have to chose between using the heat in winter or buying the medications they need. They must chose between buying a new shirt or having lunch.

I said to my young German friend, in as calm a way as I could, "Imagine, your father owned a textile factory, was a self-made wealthy man. He owned the entire apartment building and collected rent. He owned an art collection. Your mother and grandmother owned gold jewelry. But then the Nazis came and stole everything, your family was deported and killed but you alone survived. And now you live alone in a small apartment in Israel. You live with your memories, your trauma, your fears and anxiety.

You live on a small government stipend which is hardly enough to cover your basic needs. All you are asking from the German people is a little extra, to pay for heat on a cold day, to cover the cost of your medications, to have enough to eat. And...

I was asked a question....Why do we still need to pay "The Jews"?

Why? because they are still suffering, because there are no "survivors", no one has really "survived". There are Witnesses to the greatest crime ever, there are people who emerged physically not dead, but there is no one who truly survived.

To this day every survivor suffers; they, their children, their grandchildren and all of us. As one Israeli said "the Holocaust is in our DNA", we still live it.

I have a relative, lets' call her Rachel. She was only a child when "It" happened. Her parents were taken away, fate unknown to this very day. She survived four concentration camps. Today she is old, she lives in fear. Every night the ghosts come to life, the Nazis are still there, in her nightmares. She cannot be alone. She calls for her children who must travel long distances to be with her. Who is paying for those flights? Who is paying for her children to miss work?

She can no longer be alone. She cannot walk alone, she lives in fear. And she is called a "survivor".

Only those who can provide solid proof are offered any sort of compensation. The Italian insurance company Generali sold insurance policies to Jews at the start of the war. In order to cash in the policies the survivors had to provide proof and documents. Sadly there were no deposit boxes at Auschwitz for Jews to store their documents. The insurance companies demanded death certificates and asked why the policy holders did not continue to pay their premiums!

Generali sold thousands of policies to Holocaust victims, many other European insurance companies did the same. And I was asked a question, why do "The Jews" continue to demand money, why can't we let the past go?

"…he  estimates that Generali had coverage on about 110,000 Jews at the time, and he estimates this be worth $4.5 billion today." (International Herald Tribune, January 30, 2007)

We are here to raise awareness. We are here to protect. We are here so that others will not be allowed to forget the past. We are here to teach.

IKI Krav Maga is not only about physical self-defense, it is also about personal emotional survivor, of individuals and of nations.

We must learn to become aware of danger, to ourselves and to your families, to our world that we share. We must learn to stand up to injustice.

I was asked a question....and as long as God gives me I will be here to answer.

Come to Israel
Experience Israel The Krav Maga Way

Come to Israel, immerse yourself in Krav Maga, Israeli and Jewish culture and go home a changed person. Become a real Krav Maga instructor or student. Go beyond technique, learn the spirit of Krav Maga. 

For more information

Krav Maga Tour and Train Israel Experience

Sample Itinerary


Register Tour and Train

Please note that all fields followed by an asterisk must be filled in.