February 26, 2013
The issue seems to come up
now and then. People write me or ask about "Military Krav Maga" or being
"IDF certified". (IDF - Israel Defense Forces)
I guess it makes sense that if you live outside of Israel, and are unfamiliar with Israeli life and culture, that you might come to the conclusion that being "IDF certified" in Krav Maga makes you the "cream de la cream"; the best of the best.
Sadly, this is not even close to the truth.
I know there are people who cling to myths. For many kids it is difficult to let go of Santa Claus, for many adults there are still "super heroes", and for some the Israeli Rambo is very real.
We do have super heroes in Israel. I write about them in my book, "Israel, A Nation of Warriors", but they are regular people who do super things. They are not the Israeli version of the Ninja myth. (whoops, are there people who still believe that one?)
But as they say in Israel, "you live in the movies" (ata hai be seret) along with Jennifer Lopez and that other woman, Angalia something.
Say it ain't so! sorry, so it be.
The IDF does not produce super-human-Krav-Ninjas. But Israeli society does produce a great people devoted to survival. (again, all this in great detail in my book, see below)
I do not mean to put down any IDF soldier; never! anyone who served his country is worthy of praise and our unending appreciation. Simply put; we owe our lives to our soldiers. We must never forget this. However, for the sake of clarity, it is important to explain what the terms mean.
All my information comes directly from the source; soldiers who have taken the Krav Maga course, observed the courses, active and past soldiers who know what they are talking about.
For 19 years I have been teaching Israeli kids, they all serve in the army, and they come back to me with their impressions. Of course I also have many friends and family who serve.
Most Krav Maga courses in the IDF are three weeks
long. They are not more intensive than other courses, they do not push you to
super human limits.You are not expected to go without food or sleep.
The participants in these Instructor courses are not considered,
"Combatants" or "fighters" but on the same line as workers, instructors, etc.
Guns are everywhere. Jerusalem Bus Stop. The emphasis in the military is on guns, not Krav Maga.
These soldiers can go home
for long weekends, sometimes even for the night. Again, nothing wrong with
that. Fitness instructors also go home for long weekends, as they say here;
each one and his job. Every job is important; both the cook in the kitchen and the super commando, all have a purpose.
A relative of mine, who was a commander in an elite combat unit for many years (and still is in the reserves), said, "I have met only one quality Krav Maga instructor in the IDF during my entire career. You have to understand the role of Krav Maga in the army, it is minor.
Krav Maga is not as serious as learning to shoot, or driving a tank, or strategy. As such it is not regarded with such high importance.
Krav Maga is seen as a last alternative; if you are gun is jammed you might have to use your rifle as a blunt weapon. In an extreme situation you might have to punch or kick. But it does not go beyond that.
Most of the training in the instructor course involves teaching how to maintain discipline, very little time is devoted to technique. And when they finally do get to technique it is mostly how to use the rifle as a blunt weapon. After that they learn some basic punching. As such very few of the instructors reach a high level, and those that do are the ones who came with previous extensive experience."
"Sometimes I would watch the Krav Maga class and all they were doing was playing 'capture the flag', it is not like the way you (Moshe) teach. Much of the training involves building team spirit. "
Bus stop, male and female soldiers with rifles. It is the Rifle, not the fist, that symbolizes the Military.
In addition it is important to point out that having a military rank implies nothing about ones Krav Maga ability. You can be a general or a major but that does not mean that you know Krav Maga. So why advertise …Captain Cohen, Krav Maga instructor. You might as well say, Dr. Cohen, Krav Maga instructor. Using your military rank to imply Krav Maga expertise is false advertising."
These words were echoed by many soldiers whom I asked.
My teacher of many years, perhaps one of the most famous Krav Maga instructors in the IDF, always said to me, "You are a good instructor and you should be proud of that. Never claim to be a world champion if you are not one, never claim to be a war hero if you are not one. Never make false claims."
I believe those words are very wise.
Israel, Krav Maga, the Bible, the Israel Defense Forces, and the connection between them. What makes Israel unique?
What weapons did the ancient Hebrews use?
How did they fight?
and how does it relate to us today?
The answers are in this book.
Over 250 pages, the history of Israel and the Jewish people as a fighting nation from the days of Abraham to our own times. The book covers the history and roots of Krav Maga and the modern Israeli Defense Forces. The book analyzes what makes Israeli security the best in the world.
(cover by Arie Katz)
$9.99 on Kindle