The IKI ranking system is divided into two categories; Belts, and Instructor ranks.
Belts are an approximate measure of your ability to perform the IKI Krav Maga techniques while instructor ranks are a measure of your ability to teach and pass on those same techniques. The two categories are independent.
Belts are a rough estimate of your personal ability.
No rank, no exam, no score is a perfect indication of your ability. You will simply have to learn to live with that.
There are only a few belts, White, Yellow, Orange, Green, Blue, Brown, Black. In between we have "Advanced Ranks", i.e. Yellow, Advanced Yellow, Orange, Advanced Orange. etc
Unlike a score on a math or science exam, we do not have grades of 0 to 100. In martial arts you can not earn an 87. It is more similar to the A, B, C, D, F grading system and at best it is only approximate.
As such several people will have the same rank but I can personally testify and guarantee that not a two of them will have exactly the same ability. It is simply not possible.
This can lead to jealousy and frustration. Instead of enjoying and celebrating a new rank some students will look with jealousy at another and wonder, "Why did he/she receive a higher rank than me?"
Some people do more than wonder; they openly complain and challenge the teacher. Some leave the organization in righteous indignation. Jealousy and anger can consume a person.
It is acceptable to respectfully ask, "I noticed that others are ranked higher than me, please let me know what I need to work on in order to move up to the next rank". Or, "What are you looking for in Brown Belt test" and so forth.
Ultimately a student must respect the instructor's decision. He must respect the teacher and accept the teacher's judgement about rank.
Difficulty in Ranking
Personally I find student ranking to be one of the most difficult and least pleasant parts of my position. I wish I could avoid the issue totally, but I cannot.
Of course I use what I have learned from my instructors over the years plus what I have gained from my own personal experience as a teacher and student.
What follows are a few stories. I hope our members and readers find them helpful in understanding the ranking process and the challenges it presents.
Two of my outstanding students were tested by myself and my instructor for the rank of green belt. Both passed and were awarded this important rank. A green belt is a high rank and one to be very proud of. Most students never reach this level.
The students, one male and one female, were teenagers. They were very different. The male was above average height, strong and aggressive. During the testing he was praised for his intensity. My teacher pointed out that when technique fails it is intensity that counts.
The female was below average height for a girl, but super talented. In fact during the free fighting segment she flipped a larger male student using a judo throw and terrorized most of her opponents with her swift movements.
I was very proud of both my students. Within weeks both quit training.
I had no idea why.
As I have maintained good relations with my former students (I recently attended the wedding of the female student) I have been in touch with both for many years. Eventually, each one on their own, felt a need, so many years later, to come and explain to me why they quit, Why they had left the training that they loved so much.
The male: I was terribly angry. How could you give her the same rank as me! I was so much taller, stronger, faster, I could clobber her any day of the week. I was so offended that this little girl received the same rank as me I simply could not continue. Now, as an adult, I realize how foolish I was.
The female: I was so offended. I had such skill, such finesse, I applied the techniques during actuall sparring. I defeated boys. And then you give this guy the same rank as me simply because he is big and strong!?
I could not handle this insult and so I quit. I wish I had not.
There were several students who received ranks that I did not feel they deserved. I strongly felt they were not ready for these ranks and I was frustrated that my teacher awarded them these ranks. However, I kept my mouth shut, far be it from me to challenge my teacher. I swallowed it.
Later on he felt a need to explain to me. Perhaps he sensed my frustration. He certainly did not owe me an explanation, but perhaps since I was already a teacher, and I was assisting him as well, he felt it was educational for me to hear this reasoning.
"This fellow here, he is actually dyslexic. In the time it takes you to learn ten techniques he can learn only one. I know he only did one knife technique but for him that was a huge triumph.
And this fellow. Yes, he does not train as often as you. It is because he supports his mother, his grandmother and himself. He works crazy hours. He needs this rank in order to continue teaching at the school where he is employed. He might not be up to your level but he will get there, but he must have that rank now.
And that fellow who just earned his brown belt, he is suffering from asthma. For him to last that long during the free fighting session is a huge accomplishment. So he may not have fought so well but for him it is a major personal triumph."
I was humbled.
My teacher, the "Bad Ass", the special commando tough guy, had more compassion and understanding that I had ever imagined. He fully understood each person's individual circumstances; health, family, financial status, and took all this into account.
I was humbled but I learned a very valuable lesson. I use this lesson now as a teacher. No one but me knows what is behind a certain ranking decision. No one needs to know. I have earned that right just as my teacher did.
I trained hard, very hard. In fact I am convinced that no one at the gym trained harder than me. My teacher often pointed out that I was his most dedicated student. He used to say, "As certain as I am that the sun will rise tomorrow, I am equally certain that Moshe will be here on the matt".
I know I was not the most talented but no one worked harder, no one.
When it came time for black belt testing, I was not the first to be tested. When I was tested there were others who were tested with me. One fellow in particular upset me. He was in law school, lived father away and did not train anymore near as much as I did.
Yes, I admit, he was an outstanding fighter, so carefree. But he missed training sessions and then showed up like nothing had happened. He received the same rank as me.
How could this be!
I, who had worked so hard, received no special recognition, no special rank. Nothing.
Fifteen years pass. I am at Schipol airport in the Netherlands, on my way home after a 5 day seminar. Waiting for the El Al Israel Airlines check in, I see him. Wow, what a surprise. And he is so friendly.
"What are you doing here?" I ask.
He is here with a group of Israelis, they have just run the marathon. I ask him in Dutch if he has picked up any of the language, nope, not a word. Hmm...
He asks me what I am doing here. I tell him that I have made a career of Krav Maga, earned the rank of 5th dan black belt (at the time) and was teaching seminars all over the world. He commented along the lines of...You have always been such a hard worker, so dedicated, I am not surprised.
And what about him? is he still training? did he move up the ranks, or still first dan?
He could not even remember where his black belt diploma was. For him it is just something from the past.
As I was about to board the plane I was greeted with the pleasant surprise that I was upgraded to business class.
As I sat in my comfortable chair sipping on my drink my former classmate walked on the plane. Seeing me in business class he said, "Good things happen to good people".
Again I felt ashamed. For years I was upset that we had received the same rank. I worked so hard I felt I deserved a higher rank. My teacher in his wisdom always told me, "Moshe, your day of glory will come".
And it has. I just needed to be patient, and continue to work hard.
The cream rises to the top. If you work hard and you stick with it and remain humble, your true colors will show and your day of glory will arrive. Do not waste your time being upset about the ranks of others. Just focus on your own training. In time your recognition will come.
Lengthen your own line rather than trying to cut others down. Your day will come.
While belt ranks are a measure of your ability to DO, Instructor ranks are a measure of your ability to GIVE.
We have four instructor levels at the moment: Apprentice Instructor, Assistant Instructor, Associate Instructor, and Full instructor.
Currently we have a handful of Associate Instructors but no one has yet earned Full Instructor.
ALL our instructor ranks give you full authority to teach IKI Krav Maga. All instructor ranks are an indication that I personally trust you to teach our system and I stand behind you with full support.
Question: What does a higher instructor rank give me?
Answer: 1. Like all ranks, a higher rank is simply an indication of greater ability. It is for you to know. It is a personal accomplishment. Even if it has no effect on your career it is something that you know and you should appreciate. You worked hard and earned a rank.
2. If you are using the IKI ranking system, which as an IKI instructor you should be doing, then each rank gives you more of an ability to promote your students.
For example, Apprentice Instructor can promote his/her students to yellow and orange belt. Beyond that they need to be tested by me, (in person or via video).
Assistant instructor can promote Yellow, Orange, and green belt.
Associate Instructor can promote Yellow, Orange, Green and Blue belt. (Brown and Black must be done with me as well, together with the local instructor.)
Please Note: There is no Automatic relationship between a belt rank and an instructor rank. Sometimes people ask, if I am a first dan black belt what instructor rank does that give me?
That answer is - None.
Or, the reverse, I am an Assistant Instructor, what level black belt does that make me? Again, the answer is, none.
You need to test for each category independently. It is like if you are participating in Kumite (sparring/fighting) and Kata (forms). You win third place in the Kumite free fighting tournament, what ranking does not give you in the kata tournament? None, you still need to compete in kata, they are two different categories, they measure two different qualities.
You may win fight after fight and take the first place trophy for Kumite but that does not automatically give you a rank in kata. Similarly, a first place finish in the kata category does not give you an automatic ranking in the kumite free-fighting category.
Belts measure your personal ability to do, instructor ranks measure your ability to teach. Winning a Nobel prize for literature does not mean you know how to teach English literature, winning a teaching award does not mean you are about to be signed by a publishing company and have your novel published.
Can J K Rowling teach you to write the next "Harry Potter"?, I do not know.
Being a great guitar teacher does not mean you are the next Jimi Hendrix, being the great Jimi does not automatically mean you are a great guitar teacher. We all know Hendrix was an amazing performer and guitar innovator, but was he also a great guitar teacher? I have no idea. Would you want him to teach you to play? That would be pretty cool indeed but he might be in purple haze rather than focusing on your lesson. Different abilities.
Suggested Belt Requirements
Outstanding, outstanding explanation!! This should be required reading for anyone involved in any martial art, not just Krav Maga.
(Des Brown, South Africa)
Please see IKI Membership Dues